Skip to published state

finding record / erdos

recorded

vf_437f692d0e63f437

Erdős Problem #456

Canonical assertion

declared status 'open'. Formalized: yes. Let pnp_n be the smallest prime 1(modn)\equiv 1\pmod{n} and let mnm_n be the smallest integer such that nϕ(mn)n\mid \phi(m_n). Is it true that mn<pnm_n<p_n for almost all nn? Does pn/mnp_n/m_n\to \infty for almost all nn? Are there infinitely many primes pp such that p1p-1 is the only nn for which mn=pm_n=p? Current best: Linnik's theorem implies that pnnO(1)p_n\leq n^{O(1)}. It is trivial that mnpnm_n\leq p_n always. van Doorn in the comments has noted that if n=22k+1n=2^{2k+1} then mn2nm_n\leq 2n and pn2n+1p_n\geq 2n+1. Prize: no. Tags: number theory.

Notation is rendered from the stored source. The pinned checkout remains the exact record.

  1. database_record
  2. theoretical
  3. 0 spans
  4. recorded
Provenance summary
erdos_deep:456
database_record
Jun 16, 2026, 12:00 AM
not recorded
0
Exact record identityFinding ID, frontier identity, and pinned Git source
vf_437f692d0e63f437
vfr_0a25edabc16db143
ce8ba7d934c848408e0d91caca39e938698e3fc7
03f7371b496485f761f91961027fd48198dc7e93
Exact source and rootsGit ce8ba7d934c8 and content-addressed ledgers
Commit
ce8ba7d934c848408e0d91caca39e938698e3fc7
Tree
03f7371b496485f761f91961027fd48198dc7e93
Committed
2026-07-20T19:20:20-04:00
Repository
Open source
Event log
sha256:a06797bc0d1b0e3c88a2f97507fe0832661e3992d8df41187a0aa6d3ceee9bde
Snapshot
sha256:1faedc24f040a60a22177b456c74b969a61ce8836082297b1835797a57b4fa56
Proposals
sha256:e69b38037814f2e8ca826942cfc50ab370993889be2913cac1c0b3e77711160f
Actor registry
sha256:665f3e1c48f0a50fac949681c0af01bdd28de2991f2cdc5cc4cddbe69df6311b
Artifacts
sha256:3d58619c5cfb7e28de2f344476e35c9f0b80709c996b2a1bfdb2e11496f7e1da